Please hurt or kill James (whichever is fine - I don't think he has any "proper" mansion deaths yet anyway and Beiste clearly needs more reasons to not want James fighting on the front lines). He's going to go outside as Prongs on the assumption that werewolves are the same in every world and that he won't get hurt because he's an animal. He's going to deliberately ignore warnings and go out, thinking that maybe it's Moony. EDIT: Uhhh probably for day 2 or 3. He wouldn't go until he hears there's a werewolf after all.

Tohru will be good and not go out, but she's not stupid. Even if she doesn't know exactly what's going on, she's going to leave things outside Ruby's door for her to find in the morning - whatever's happening is obviously upsetting her, so she needs some cheering up, right? Things like a little vase with flowers, or some nice warm sweet homemade rolls for breakfast. Or maybe even a basket with fresh fruit (ahahahahahahahaha I'm punny).